Keenan House in Ossining: First Taste


UPDATE: This restaurant closed, but reopened with new owners in Spring 2014.

The Keenan House in Ossining recently opened. The decor is quite beautiful with clean lines, earthy colors and contemporary furniture. When you enter, the bar is directly to the right and features about a dozen taps, 70 bottled selections, a full bar, and a wine list of approximately a dozen selections as of this writing. The selections go from a sparkling Prosecco to a few nice whites, and a short-list range of reds varying from light to bolder.

image 1

This new eatery should be considered “gastro-pub” fare. In essence, higher caliber menu offerings yet in a casual yet classy environment. Since it is located in Ossining, and Mad Men’s Don Draper resides in Ossining, one might picture him frequenting the establishment after a long day at the firm.

The restaurant is open everyday except for Monday. On Saturday, they are open until 1AM should you need a last beverage and a bite to eat on the late side of the day. On Sunday, brunch is served from 11:30 AM – 3:00 PM in addition to the regular menu being available until 9PM.

They are still working out the kinks here. Service is not consistent and we found one employee behind the bar spending more time flirting with the waitress than attending to his customer’s requests. One dining partner requested a dish, was delivered a completely different selection, and they never replaced it. Another dining friend ordered a burger and asked for the condiments, which were to be included on the plate. After a couple of requests and much waiting, the burger was cold and he lost interest. I was excited at the prospect of hand-cut fries but they arrived soggy and laden with oil which is an indicator that the oil in the fryer is not hot enough. In addition, the food is not properly seasoned overall leaving the patron to self-season; the food tends to be on the bland side.

This restaurant has much potential, but a lack of training and supervision worries me that it will do them in. We want a local establishment like this to succeed but they must do their part. C’mon guys, we can do this! Let’s make this work.

image 2

Beautifully designed bar, many taps and beer offerings. Love the Edison lighting

image 3

Nicely designed contemporary dining room  – clean lines, welcoming color tones

image 4

Traditional eggs benedict. Nicely plated, but lacked seasoning

image 5

Nice selection of Hudson Valley cheeses from Chaseholm Farm: Camembert and Chèvre

image 6

Keenan Burger on brioche with choice of cheese – – did not arrive with the onion relish

image 7

Filet and eggs benedict in a red wine reduction – – a little short on the reduction

image 8

Delicious sorbet and whimsical plating


The Keenan House – Kitchen & Tap Room 

199 Main Street

Ossining, NY 10562



Monday Closed
Tuesday 11:30am-10pm
Wednesday 11:30am-10pm
Thursday 11:30am-11pm
Friday/Saturday 11:30am-1am
Sunday 11:30am-9pm, brunch served 11:30am-3pm

You can read more reviews by Todd Matthews at


About Author

Anjanette Delgado is the mobile editor at The Journal News and She's working on tablet and smartphone publishing. She came to The Journal News from California, where she was the managing editor of The Salinas Californian and El Sol newspapers. Twitter: @AnjDelgado

Leave A Reply